Softwood lumber prices drop as Autumn arrives
October 21, 2020 By Madison's Lumber Reporter
Last week producer and wholesaler dimension softwood lumber prices across North America dropped, as expected for this time of year. However, U.S. housing starts data for September 2020 is incredibly strong, so the expectation is that — given ongoing very high demand — asking prices will not approach the low levels of 2019. It is safe to say that a price floor has been reached, although where exactly that will land remains to be seen. Madison’s Lumber Reporter expects that by U.S. Thanksgiving this year, we will know the “new bottom” for lumber prices, and that January 2021 will see a return to hot demand for construction framing lumber commodities.
The sales price of most softwood lumber continued their recent drops last week, except benchmark items Western S-P-F KD 2×4 R/L and benchmark panel commodities Oriented Strand Board and Plywood (Ontario). This suggest an ongoing sellers market, and that producers are able to sustain manufacturing volumes based on their sawmill strong order files. Suppliers don’t need to lower prices to close sales; instead focusing on making wood already ordered and getting previously-sold materials out to waiting customers. The biggest pickle right now remains to be transportation, as trucks are still difficult to source and expected rail cars are not arriving.
“Western S-P-F prices held firm, Eastern S-P-F plummeted again, and panels’ price were flat.” — Madison’s Lumber Reporter
Producers of Western S-P-F commodities in the United States reported flat pricing last week as overall demand was stalled. Prompt availability popped up with increasing regularity as both primary and secondary suppliers dealt below print levels when terms seemed prudent. While prices were flat from the previous week’s levels on dimension, studs took a tumble as stud mills tried to entice reluctant buyers. Demand remained strong in most regions with pent-up construction activity robust where weather permitted, but new purchases last week were infrequent as customers instead focussed on digesting incoming wood.
It was another quiet week according to Western S-P-F lumber producers in Canada. The trend of cautious customers sitting on their hands and waiting for previously-booked orders to arrive persisted, and suppliers spent much of the week tracking down shipments for irate buyers. While sawmills held their dimension prices firm at the previous week’s levels, wholesalers and distributers captured the majority of fill-in sales with more flexible pricing and quicker shipment times.
For the week ending Oct. 16, 2020 the price of benchmark softwood lumber commodity item Western S-P-F KD 2×4 #2&Btr continued to remain firm, at U.S. $960 mfbm, said Madison’s Lumber Reporter. This price is unchanged from one month ago. Compared to one year ago, this price is up an amazing +$590, or +160%.
“Western S-P-F sawmills in the U.S. enjoyed two-week order files, while those in Canada were running wood ordered three weeks ago. Order files at each were shrinking as supply caught up with demand, however normally for this time of year order files are approximately three days so prices for benchmark Western Spruce-Pine-Fir are not expected to drop significantly any time soon.” — Madison’s Lumber Reporter
Compared to one-year-ago, last week’s Western S-P-F KD 2×4 #2&Btr price was +$445, or +86%, higher than the one-year rolling average price of U.S. $515 mfbm and was up +$521, or +117%, compared to the two-year rolling average price of U.S. $439 mfbm.
The below table is a comparison of recent highs, in June 2018, and current Oct. 2020 benchmark dimension Softwood Lumber 2×4 prices compared to historical highs of 2004/05 and compared to recent lows of Sept. 2015:
Print this page